She tilted her head slightly to the side, studying him carefully. A gentle and kind person, she hated seeing others suffering or in pain, and her mother's cousin positively radiated such burdens. His fëa seemed heavy and wounded, and she wanted very badly to help ease his pain.
"And why is that?" She asked. "You have done ill deeds, yes, but that does not mean you do not feel, and it does not mean you do not deserve to mourn."
Those with kind hearts can easily be used. Maedhros doesn't want to draw her into his dark world; she doesn't deserve that. He needs to lead her to a safe path - away from him and the curse he bears.
"I could mourn all the Ages of Arda and it would not be enough. This is part of the punishment I have rightly receive from the Valar." his deep voice is gentle and patient, "I am best forgotten, hína."
Her parents would certainly appreciate his efforts to deter her. They were well aware of their daughter's nature, and often worried that others would take advantage of her sweet nature. However, Celebrian was also a stubborn creature, and she did not give up easily.
"I disagree." She replied, ignoring the fact that he called her a child, something that she disliked immensely. "I do not think you ought to be forgotten."
"I also think that while the Valar punish you, you also punish yourself." She continued.
no subject
Celebrian may be young, but she was wise beyond her years, and was no stranger to loss.
no subject
"I am...undeserving."
no subject
"And why is that?" She asked. "You have done ill deeds, yes, but that does not mean you do not feel, and it does not mean you do not deserve to mourn."
no subject
"I could mourn all the Ages of Arda and it would not be enough. This is part of the punishment I have rightly receive from the Valar." his deep voice is gentle and patient, "I am best forgotten, hína."
no subject
"I disagree." She replied, ignoring the fact that he called her a child, something that she disliked immensely. "I do not think you ought to be forgotten."
"I also think that while the Valar punish you, you also punish yourself." She continued.
"You are not as terrible as you think you are."